© Copyright 2010 The Times Leader. All Rights Reserved.
The Times Leader 15 N. Main Street Wilkes-Barre, PA 18711
(570) 829-7101 or (800) 427-8649
Northeastern Pennsylvania's Home Page
BILL KELLY asked us over to his house the other night for some light conversation, a couple of drinks and hors d’oeuvres.
Kelly is the amiable president of WVIA, deep-throated as an old radio and broadcast pro should be, and also a man who is pensive, often deep in thought.
One of the areas that command his attention is media and why shouldn’t it? He is the heart and face of public broadcasting in Northeast Pennsylvania. His show “State of Pennsylvania” is a long-running and highly popular staple of the station.
Media has been his life, starting at a radio station in his early teens and becoming a general manager of one by the time he was 19 or 20. He can’t stop thinking and talking long enough to pin it down the exact date of his management career but who’s counting?
So, Kelly wanted to talk about media in general but newspapers in particular. Come on over, he said, to his house — the WVIA studios in Jenkins Township.
The drinks were water. And the hors d’oeurves were tidbits of information from magazines and newspapers predicting the eventual death of print. Newspapers are dying, say many folks.
Along with my invitation to discuss the state of the newspaper business, Kelly also asked the publisher of the Williamsport Gazette and co-publisher of the Citizens Voice to join us.
So, on Thursday night there we were under the lights in the new high definition studio with a live audience trying to explain why we believe we’ll have a job at a newspaper in a few years.
I knew what I wanted to say but how could I?
After all, I was in Bill Kelly’s house for some lively and animated conversation. Manners trump convenience and candor or at least brutal honesty in these matters.
And, with Times Leader employees and assorted friends of the paper dominating the audience I wanted to give them their money’s worth: an hour of discussion on a business they love.
But, we could have finished the conversation in a flash. Here’s the truth about the future of print: It’s not going away.
An industry going though change is not necessarily one that is dying. More than 100 million adults read a newspaper every day.
Newspapers are the second largest medium for advertising behind television.
At The Times Leader, our Sunday circulation just rose eight percent. We carry more than 70 percent of all the print advertising in Wilkes-Barre and have an even higher share of the dollars spent on newspaper advertising here.
We lose some revenue every day and we also add new revenue. We have added more than $1 million of new revenue in this year alone.
“Yes, but my kids do not read the newspaper,” cry the newspaper doomsday folks. “They use the Internet and they twitter and tweet and text.”
Now remember, manners are gone here. And my response to that is this: “So?”
For those folks who talk about young people not reading newspapers, let me ask this question.
How many young persons read a newspaper 20 or 30 years ago?
Not many. The difference is we did not see young people in those years staring into a computer screen or tapping out the new version of Morse Code on a PDA.
Here are some things you cannot do on the Internet.
You can’t put the story you read there on the refrigerator, especially the one about your child’s birthday or graduation.
You will never see that amazing story that you stumble upon when leafing through the pages of a newspaper. It’s the story you would read if you knew it was there but you will never know looking on the Internet.
The paper is a tactile experience. It has a feel and a smell. It has a personality. It’s a friend brought to your doorstep by a human being, delivered each morning before you awake.
Yes, a newspaper is part of a changing business. We do not know exactly what the business will look like next year or the year after or the next for that matter. What we know is that it is not dying.
There have been predictions about the death of newspapers for decades and we are still here.
Our biggest threats come from within. Newspapers have been highly profitable and easy to manage for decades and decades. It’s tough now. Poor and misguided and unprepared management is being exposed and we run inaccurate stories about how advertising is migrating to the Web.
No it isn’t.
Less money is being spent on advertising everywhere. Period. Several online sites such as AOL have revenue declines that in some cases are double the newspaper advertising declines.
And we have been totally aloof at best with our customers. In the worst case we have been obnoxious and rude and bullies in our communities and with customers.
Can’t get away with that any longer.
We need to stop wasting time talking about the Internet and all the sexy new technology that does this and that with news content. We need to be blunt.
Someone wants to talk to us about newspapers dying?
Unless it’s our sincere and gracious friend Bill Kelly asking we need to answer directly.
Let’s talk about something worthwhile and real. Our time is valuable and we need not engage in these discussions in order to appear deep and thoughtful and “with it.” Newspapers are not going away. That’s the way it is and that’s the way it’s going to be.
Richard L. Connor is Editor and Publisher of the Times Leader and president of Wilkes-Barre Publishing Company.
Richard L. Connor is Editor and Publisher of The Times Leader. Mr. Connor’s career in the newspaper business spans nearly 40 years in four states and in a variety of positions including editor, publisher and owner.
In June of 2006, Mr. Connor formed The Wilkes-Barre Publishing Company, purchased The Times Leader and returned to the post he previously held from 1978 to 1986.
He has worked for several media companies, including 25 years as an executive with Capital Cities Communications, later Cap Cities/ABC and then the Walt Disney Company. During that time he served for over 10 years as President and Publisher of The Fort Worth Star-Telegram in Fort Worth, TX.
His work to have his newspapers not only serve the community as a voice of needed change but also to build bridges among its leaders and diverse forces has been recognized constantly for its unique brand of media leadership. He has won numerous awards as a columnist and for his editorials and has received a number of awards for his newspaper and community leadership and achievement. He has served on numerous community and industry boards, including two times as a member of the Pulitzer Prize Nominating Committee.
He resides in the Back Mountain with his wife, Deborah, and daughter, Meredith. Mr. Connor also has two adult children.
Americans show spirit time and again Richard L. Connor Opinion
Brown’s win referendum on Obama Richard L. Connor OPINION
Gaming law a weak way to govern Richard L. Connor Opinion
Love Kindled, and thwarted, by technology Richard L. CONNOR Opinion
Yes Meredith, there is a Santa Claus Richard L. Connor OPINION
Lean to the left is worthy of comments Richard L. Connor Opinion
At the 19th hole soaking up all the Tiger humor Richard L. Connor OPINION
Predictions for 2010: Obama will start job Richard L. Connor OPINION
Newspapers face change, not death Richard L. Connor Opinion
There’s still hope for our county court Richard L. Connor Opinion
a4mrnepansidr said...
My vocations remove me from my beloved NEPA quite often; therefore access to WVIA was removed with reliance upon Mr. Collin’s editorial regarding this topic. Concur in principle on most parts; however, while the discussion must have been more developed on “State of Pa”, one would be remiss not to address one crucial point. HONORABLE Judge Wilkinson of 4th Cir.App opined in his 8.02.09 Decision a number of concerns regarding the demise of print in a 1rst Amend Case. Read the opinion for this note cannot do justice. In essence, the future will all boil down to responsible, sound, ethical…good investigative journalism. My comment is anybody can ‘hang out a shingle’ on the internet these days void of accountability, training… Just some fodder while the St Pete Times just arrived at the hotel…(5:45 am)…stale news now…thank you for the net!!!
November 22, 2009 at 5:48 AM
a4mrnepansidr said...
May have written Collins for Connor. Always get these Irish names confused. Told you journalism should be left to the professionals. Ahh, he'll get over it, after 40+ years in journalism, certain he has been called worse. Long live the First Amendment!
November 22, 2009 at 6:03 AM
Rolie Ciffo said...
Newspapers would do a lot better if opinion were limited to the op/ed page. That's the problem with the NY Times & Wash Post. Journalism students go to Columbia Univ & want to "change the world" immediately rather than paying their dues & getting promoted to the op/ed page. Editors need to do a better job ensuring the news page contains only news & opinion is limited to the op/ed page. As far as Mr Kelly, what problem does he have? He's got the federal gov't giving him funds so we can see Bill Moyers carry liberal water every night. Fox News is not the problem. Moyers was there first. Fox News is "equal time" for the Center-Right in this country.
November 22, 2009 at 7:44 AM
Dave Levy said...
So, just to clarify, the future of the newspaper is the fact that people like me (a 25-year-old who stares at a screen most of the day) will get sick of it and mature to the Newspaper? But how could I leave a comment to the editor of the paper when I grow up and get over this screen? Sir, I absolutely respect your opinion, but you are relying on tradition, in fact the furthest possible thing from change, as a justification for the future of your industry. When the day comes that I cross the bridge into life events announcing engagements, marriages, children, and professional success, I will certainly buy that hard copy. But I will also be able to e-mail a copy to my family nationwide wherever they may be - instantaneously. And in terms of discovery: I found this article, didn't I? Google, to be honest, and then I'll link to it on Twitter and more people will find it. Serendipity is a fun way to read a newspaper, but it certainly isn't the only avenue for discovery.
November 22, 2009 at 7:49 AM
Justice said...
Long winded ramblings such as this are one reason newspapers throughout the country have been falling like flies. Instead of an editorial page promotion of the Leader, accompanied by anecdotal evidence, perhaps a factual recount on newspaper closings would add some enlightenment to the question..
November 22, 2009 at 9:08 AM
George said...
Our seemingly endless scandals of official corruption are an excellent, if not unique, opportunity to do a real reporting job and tie it all together. Surely the tale is Pulitzer worthy, if well enough told.
November 22, 2009 at 9:17 AM
Jessica said...
The newspaper industry is struggling across much of America. Yet, you see it thriving in a city like Wilkes-Barre, a two newspaper town. I believe these papers survive and will continue to do so, because of their talented sales forces and their passion to present unbiased information to their readers. The other papers that have failed, had succumbed to the liberal mainstream media way of reporting news. The Times Leader and the Citizen's Voice have the journalistic integrity that other papers lack. They have uncovered corruption and have served to protect the citizens of Luzerne County. The competition brings out the best in both papers. We are very fortunate to have both.
November 22, 2009 at 10:01 AM
George Bulgaris said...
As a person that has previously been in the newspaper business for over 40 years, I too agree with Rich Connor. Newspapers are essential when a person wants to know the whole story and whats behind the story. Can you imagine what it could have been like to not get the full story and the background associated with some of the biggest news events of our recent times. ie, Middle East wars, swine flu, shenanigans of our local as well as national political figures. Pick up the paper, squeeze it between your fingers and immerse yourself into the world of story telling. You just can't beat it.
November 22, 2009 at 6:27 PM
Scott said...
If not for these rules, the industry's numbers would look even worse. Average weekday circulation at 379 U.S. newspapers fell 10.6 percent during the six months ending in September. That was the steepest decline ever recorded by the Audit Bureau of Circulations, the organization that verifies how many people are paying to read publications.
November 23, 2009 at 12:17 AM
Lisa said...
I could not imagine a world without newspapers! The feel of the recycled paper, the ink sometimes left behind, the smell! I love me some Times Leader and hope that never goes away!!
November 23, 2009 at 11:57 AM
Most Viewed 1 Richard Connor Column Stories in Past 7 Days
1. Americans show spirit time and again Richard L. Connor Opinion
2. Newspapers face change, not death Richard L. Connor Opinion
3. Brown’s win referendum on Obama Richard L. Connor OPINION
4. Democracy failed me but column can’t Richard L Connor Opinion
5. At the 19th hole soaking up all the Tiger humor Richard L. Connor OPINION
6. Love Kindled, and thwarted, by technology Richard L. CONNOR Opinion
7. Predictions for 2010: Obama will start job Richard L. Connor OPINION
8. Yes Meredith, there is a Santa Claus Richard L. Connor OPINION